Unionised GPs are refusing to co-operate with police over health records

23 June 2016 – GPs’ trade unions up and down the country are digging their heels in and refusing to co-operate with police over sharing shooters’ health data, it has emerged.

According to a report in the Guardian today, doctors are complaining that they’re not being paid enough for filling out and returning medical forms to the police.

A Dr John Canning of Middlesbrough told the paper: “Under the old system, GPs were asked, ‘do you have concerns?’ after licences were given, which is a bit like closing the stable doors after the horses have bolted.”

This is a falsehood. Doctors were consulted, under the old system, during the process of issuing a firearm or shotgun certificate if the applicant told the police about a relevant medical condition.

Concerningly, a minor doctors’ trade union in Devon has developed proformas with which GPs can refuse to comply with police demands for shooters’ data (PDF here). The concern is because if the police are denied unrestricted access to shooters’ medical data by a GP for whatever reason, they may well simply refuse to issue or vary certificates.

The new medical system for shooters, introduced in April, expects GPs to routinely inform on shooters’ health to the police, supplying them with fresh data as it becomes available to the doctor. Firearm and shotgun certificate application forms now require shooters to waive their rights under the Data Protection Act, which ensure doctors can only process your medical information for genuine medical purposes.

Many shooters have privately voiced concern that their doctor is no longer someone they can trust, particularly when it comes to mental health concerns, as there is a strong risk of an inappropriate certificate revocation and a police raid on your home if a risk-averse policeman with no knowledge or understanding of mental health conditions sees certain trigger phrases.

It is likely, given the behaviour of the British Medical Association trade union earlier this year in relation to junior doctors’ contracts, that the doctors will suddenly change their tune if more money is dangled before them. Much of the literature from the BMA on firearms centres around whether a fee can be charged and who should pay it.

6 thoughts on “Unionised GPs are refusing to co-operate with police over health records

  1. Chris Kinealy

    Dear Ladies/Gentlemen
    I worked as a trained Mental Health Nurse for THIRTY EIGHT YEARS, much of it in prisons, police stataions and other custodial institutions. And I am here to tell you that NO-ONE. Not a doctor, nurse, psychiatrist or indeed ANYONE can predict the future. As everone knows we have the strictest firearms laws in the ENTIRE WORLD and armed crime keeps on rising. The medicine does not work so lets have a stronger dose of it. When will people realise that criminals break laws. Law abiding people are the only ones affected by LAWS. If banning things worked then we would not have crime because crime is already banned. When guns are outlawed then only outlaws wil have guns. The only thing that will stop a bad guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun.


    Liked by 1 person

    1. Jerry

      Well said, Mr. Kinealy! I wish we could get our politicians to stop talking long enough to listen to your words!
      Jerry, from across the pond.


      1. Chris Kinealy

        Dear Jerry
        Many thanks for your support Jerry. In 1776 we fought a totally meaningless war against you guys. I actually think that you were right. Unlike Mr Obama! But we are on the same side against the latest enemy. These ISIS bastards who hate everyone; Christians, gays, Americans, British, women, EVERYONE.

        CHRIS. .


Leave a Reply to Chris Kinealy Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s